Pre-refund VAT audit: what happens when the tax authority holds back funds?

← Back to Blog

Have you submitted your VAT refund claim, but the funds haven't arrived? Here is how a pre-refund NAV audit works, how long it can take, and how to prepare for it.

Let us walk through what happens in the following situation. A company files a VAT return containing a substantial refund claim, calculates when the money is expected to arrive, and builds it into its cash flow forecast. The deadline passes, and nothing happens on the bank account. A few days later, an audit authorisation letter arrives in the company's Cégkapu electronic mailbox. This is a pre-refund audit. In practice it is one of the most thorough examinations in Hungarian tax procedure, and its most important consequence is unambiguous: the money does not move until the audit is closed.

Why an audit is ordered before the refund is paid

The tax authority has a statutory deadline for paying out reclaimed VAT — 30 or 75 days, depending on the taxpayer's classification and status. If, however, NAV orders an audit before the refund is made, the clock on the payment deadline stops until the examination is completed.

Ordering an audit is not arbitrary. NAV's risk-analysis system screens returns automatically, and in the following situations an audit is close to inevitable:

  • A first significant refund claim by a newly established company.
  • A sudden increase in deductible VAT compared with previous periods.
  • A major investment: the purchase of real estate, the acquisition of machinery, or an expansion of production capacity.
  • A foreign-owned start-up company.
  • Higher-risk sectors: construction, metal trading, electronics wholesale, agricultural products, temporary staffing, and transport.
  • A high proportion of exports or intra-Community supplies, where the output side is exempt while deductible VAT accumulates on the input side.
  • A risky partner in the supply chain — even where the taxpayer was unaware of it.

What NAV actually examines

Many people assume that the authority merely checks the formal requirements of the invoices. The invoice, however, is only the starting point. The purpose of the audit is to establish whether the economic transaction shown on the invoice actually took place in reality, precisely between the parties indicated and with the content indicated.

The right of deduction does not arise automatically from the issuing of a document. The authority pays particular attention to the following:

  • The substance of the transaction. Is there a written contract, a purchase order, a certificate of completion? Did the goods physically move (consignment note, CMR, goods receipt note)? In the case of services, what is the tangible, demonstrable result?
  • The supplier's capacity. Did the partner have the human and physical resources necessary to perform (employees, equipment, premises)?
  • The supply chain. NAV may also examine earlier participants in the supply chain. If tax avoidance occurred at an earlier point in the chain, this may affect the final purchaser as well.
  • Due care — the subjective element. In line with the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union and Hungarian practice, the right to deduct VAT may be denied where the authority proves that the taxpayer knew, or with the care that could reasonably be expected of it should have known, that it was participating in a transaction connected with tax fraud. The rights of a good-faith and diligent purchaser are protected, but diligent conduct must be evidenced by documents.
  • Payment of the consideration. Under Section 186 of the Hungarian VAT Act, the refund is conditional on the consideration for the invoice having been paid by the time the return is filed. The VAT on unpaid invoices cannot be refunded and must be carried forward by the taxpayer to the next period.

The authority's toolkit

During the audit, NAV may carry out the following procedural acts:

  • Requests for documents, with short deadlines, typically a few days.
  • On-site inspection, at the registered seat, the site of operations, or the warehouse.
  • Statements taken from the taxpayer's legal representative.
  • Witness hearings. The authority may summon the company's employees, its accountant, its subcontractors or other business partners as witnesses. Giving testimony is a statutory obligation, and it carries a duty to tell the truth.
  • Related audits at suppliers and customers.
  • Requests for data from banks, transport companies and other authorities.

How long can the procedure take?

The basic statutory time limit for a tax audit is 30 or 90 days, which may be extended in justified cases. Although the duration of related audits and of requests to foreign authorities suspends the procedural deadline, under the applicable legislation a pre-refund audit may last for a maximum of 180 days.

Where a more complex procedure involving a supply-chain examination becomes protracted, this represents a significant liquidity risk, since the amount claimed remains blocked throughout. This shortfall is worth building into financial planning in advance.

If the audit is closed without a finding of unlawfulness, the tax authority is required to pay the taxpayer statutory interest for the period of the delayed refund.

Preparing before the refund claim is filed

The outcome of a pre-refund audit is not decided when the audit authorisation letter is received, but earlier — through orderly documentation prepared in advance.

A checklist to run through before filing the return:

  1. Contracts and purchase orders. A written agreement should be available for every material transaction.
  2. Evidence of performance. Certificates of completion, handover records, work sheets, photographic documentation.
  3. Logistics documents. Consignment notes (CMR), goods receipt notes, weighbridge tickets.
  4. Documented partner checks. Verification of the validity of the tax number, of VIES status and of authority to represent — saved and dated as at the date of performance.
  5. Financial settlement. Bank statements, with payments clearly traceable to the corresponding invoices.
  6. Business correspondence. Retained e-mails, quotations and records of negotiations.
  7. Consistency of data. Full alignment between the contract, the invoice, the transport document and the accounting entries.

Common mistakes during the procedure

  • Ignoring requests for information. Missing deadlines results in procedural fines.
  • Producing documents after the event. Identifying back-dated documents is part of an auditor's routine practice, and doing so carries serious legal and tax consequences.
  • Failing to prepare witnesses. Employees summoned as witnesses must be informed of their rights, their obligations, and the importance of factual accuracy.
  • Answering beyond the question. Answers should be given to the questions actually asked, and in accordance with the facts — nothing more.
  • Forgoing remedies. Observations may be submitted within 15 days of receipt of the audit report. This is the most important stage at which incorrect findings can be corrected before the decision is issued.

Consequences of an adverse finding

If the authority issues an adverse decision, a tax penalty and late payment interest may be imposed in addition to the tax shortfall. The general rate of the tax penalty is 50% of the shortfall, while in cases involving concealment of income or falsification of documents it may reach 200%. The decision may be challenged by way of appeal and, subsequently, before the administrative courts.

A pre-refund audit is best regarded as part of normal business operations. With proper documentation and advance risk assessment, the delays and financial risks arising from the procedure can be significantly reduced.


Do you have questions about the above? Our team at Everest Accounting is ready to help!